Skip to content

A 12-year-old Chinese girl and the eternal question: Wunderkinder are too valuable for the Olympic system to set strict age limits

The example of Yu Zidi, who is competing in the 200-metre medley final at the World Championships in Singapore today, has reignited the debate: how young can a professional athlete be, and how old must they be to compete in major competitions? What constitutes child labour? What should be banned?

World Aquatics database.

With regular irregularity, heated public discussions arise when the Olympic circus produces child prodigies. Depending on the nation and cardinal direction in which these prodigies appear, the arguments for and against are distorted beyond recognition. The latest example is the 12-year-old Chinese swimmer Yu Zidi, who will not celebrate her thirteenth birthday until 16 October – but who, in a few hours, could win a World Championship medal in the, well, adult competition in Singapore.

Sensational stories get clicks. In all its silly imperfection, this quote sums up the majority of the so-called reporting on Yu Zidi:

"However, Yu was granted special permission due to her outstanding times. She discovered her passion for swimming at the age of six when she was escaping the summer heat. ‘My father took me to a water park. One day, a coach came up to me and asked if I wanted to swim faster.’"

But the key question should really be: what came first, incredible times or thousands of hours of hard work?

The answer is clear.

But the answer is rarely given.

And I'm not even talking about another aspect of various fabulous achievements, I'm not even talking about doping.

This post is for subscribers only

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In

Latest

Podcast: CAS confirms corruption in World Triathlon elections

Podcast: CAS confirms corruption in World Triathlon elections

Perhaps you would prefer to listen to the story about corruption in World Triathlon that I published this afternoon? Some people find that more convenient. So here is a podcast – in English and Spanish. Enjoy! All you have to do is sign up for the newsletter; no paid subscription is necessary.

Members Public
CAS confirms corruption in World Triathlon elections

CAS confirms corruption in World Triathlon elections

EXCLUSIVE: The head of the American confederation, Liber García (Uruguay), rigged elections with other continental princes and the then secretary general Antonio Arimany. The new triathlon boss Arimany is also ICAS vice president. An opposition is calling for an investigation and new elections.

Members Public
Fencing and the FIE: the Russian way of solving problems

Fencing and the FIE: the Russian way of solving problems

447 fencers and the European Confederation's board speak out against the decision of the International Fencing Federation to allow Russian fencers and teams to compete as ‘neutral athletes.’ At the same time, Usmanov's vassals around Vitaly Logvin consolidate their power with a dubious congress.

Members Public